What are the different types of underlayment

Underlayment is a critical layer in any flooring system. It sits between the subfloor and the finished flooring, providing essential support, moisture protection, and sound insulation. Picking the right underlayment is key to a long-lasting, high-performing floor.

Picking the right underlayment is crucial for any flooring project. It is not just an extra layer; it is an essential component that impacts the floor’s durability, comfort, and overall performance. As a quality control manager with extensive experience in underlayment manufacturing, I have seen firsthand how the right choice makes all the difference. This article will explore the different types of underlayment available, their applications, and what factors you should consider when making your selection.

We will now look at the basics of underlayment, moving from its fundamental definition to its key functions, to help you better understand its role in flooring systems.

---

What is underlayment?

Underlayment is a thin material layer placed on top of a subfloor to provide a smooth, stable, and protective surface for the finished flooring. It offers support, moisture resistance, sound dampening, and insulation, enhancing the floor’s longevity and performance.

Underlayment and subfloor are often confused, but they serve distinct purposes. The sous-plancher is the structural base, usually plywood or concrete, which supports the entire floor system. The sous-couche, on the other hand, is a non-structural layer installed on top of the subfloor, specifically designed to improve the performance of the finished flooring material. I have witnessed projects where skipping this step led to premature flooring failure, causing issues like unevenness, noise, and moisture damage.

Underlayment’s main functions

• Moisture Barrier/Vapor Retarder: Underlayment acts as a protective layer, stopping moisture from the subfloor from reaching and damaging the finished flooring. This is very important in basements or areas prone to humidity, preventing issues like warping in wood or mold growth under other materials.
• Sound Damping/Absorption: Many underlayments help reduce noise, both impact sound within the room (like footsteps) and sound transmission to rooms below. This is important for multi-story buildings and apartments, where Classe d'isolation contre les chocs (IIC) et Classe de transmission du son (STC) ratings are key performance indicators. For example, a good underlayment can improve a floor’s IIC rating by 10-20 points.
• Leveling and Cushioning: Underlayment can smooth out minor imperfections in the subfloor, providing a more even surface for flooring. Some types also offer a soft cushion, which adds comfort underfoot and reduces fatigue, especially important in commercial settings or kitchens.
• Isolation thermique : Some underlayments offer insulation, helping to maintain room temperature and potentially reduce energy costs. Materials with a higher R-value provide better thermal resistance. I have observed this feature is frequently underestimated in optimizing indoor climate.
• Extends Flooring Life and Improves Performance: By providing a stable, protected base, underlayment helps prevent common issues like warping, gapping, and squeaking, extending the lifespan of your flooring. This protection minimizes stress on the flooring material itself, preserving its appearance and structural integrity over time.

Selecting the appropriate underlayment is essential for the long-term success of any flooring installation. Understanding the different types available and their specific benefits will allow you to make an informed decision for your project.

Now, we will explore the common types of underlayment, detailing their compositions, applications, and their advantages and disadvantages.

---

What are the common underlayment types?

Common underlayment types include felt, foam, rubber, cork, plywood/OSB, cement board, and self-leveling compounds. Each type offers unique benefits for specific flooring materials and installation needs, addressing concerns from moisture to noise reduction.

As a quality control manager, I understand the nuances of each underlayment type and their suitability for different applications. This section dives into the specifics of the most common underlayment materials.

Felt Underlayment (Asphalt-Saturated Felt/Tar Paper)

Felt underlayment is made from asphalt-saturated felt or tar paper. This material is popular for its moisture resistance and low cost, typically available in 15lb or 30lb weights. It is often used under hardwood and laminate flooring to provide a basic vapor retarder and minor slip resistance. It is also historically used as a roofing underlayment. Its primary advantages include moisture protection and affordability, though its sound-dampening properties are minimal, generally offering no significant STC/IIC improvement. From my experience, it provides an adequate vapor barrier but offers little in terms of cushioning.

Foam Underlayment

Foam underlayment is typically made from polyethylene or polypropylene, often ranging from 2mm to 6mm thick. It is a lightweight and cost-effective option commonly used under laminate, engineered wood, and luxury vinyl plank (LVP) flooring. Its advantages include sound absorption, cushioning for walking comfort, and some moisture resistance, depending on the thickness and presence of an integrated vapor barrier. A standard foam underlayment can offer an IIC rating improvement of 5-10 points. I often recommend thicker foam underlayments for projects prioritizing comfort and minor sound reduction, especially in residential settings.

Rubber Underlayment

Rubber underlayment is made from recycled rubber, providing excellent density and resilience. It is known for its superior durability, excellent sound insulation, and shock absorption. It is often used under tile, natural stone, and in high-traffic commercial areas where noise reduction is critical, achieving significant STC and IIC improvements, often increasing IIC ratings by 15-25 points. While it is more expensive and heavier than other options (e.g., weighing 1-2 lbs per square foot), its performance in commercial and high-end residential projects makes it worthwhile. I’ve personally seen how well it performs in reducing impact noise in multi-story buildings, meeting strict building codes for sound attenuation.

Cork Underlayment

Cork underlayment comes from natural cork, a sustainable and renewable resource. It offers excellent sound and thermal insulation, making it an eco-friendly choice. It is compatible with a wide range of flooring types, including hardwood, laminate, LVP, and tile. Cork is praised for its environmental benefits, superior sound dampening (often improving IIC ratings by 10-20 points), and insulation properties (with an R-value of approximately 3.0 per inch of thickness), but it is generally more expensive than foam or felt. In my work, I find cork to be an ideal solution for projects requiring premium soundproofing and a natural, sustainable material.

Plywood/Oriented Strand Board (OSB) Underlayment

Plywood and OSB underlayment are wood-based panels available in various grades, typically 1/4" to 3/4" thick. They are used to create a smooth, stable subfloor surface, especially for resilient flooring (like vinyl and linoleum) and tile where a perfectly flat and rigid base is critical. They provide excellent structural support and leveling capabilities for minor subfloor imperfections. However, they are sensitive to moisture and can swell if exposed to excessive water, which can lead to flooring failure. I typically specify exterior-grade plywood (like marine-grade) for moisture-prone areas to enhance durability and stability.

Cement Board Underlayment (CBU)

Cement board underlayment is made from cement, aggregates, and glass mesh, making it dimensionally stable and highly resistant to water. It is ideal for tile and natural stone installations, especially in high-moisture areas like bathrooms, kitchens, and showers. CBU provides an uncoupling layer that helps prevent cracks in the tile caused by subfloor movement. Its benefits include excellent water resistance and stability, adherence to ANSI A118.10 standards for tile installation, but it is heavy (e.g., a 3×5 foot panel can weigh 30-40 lbs) and can be difficult to cut without specialized tools. I have found cement board to be indispensable for achieving durable, long-lasting tile installations in wet environments.

Self-Leveling Underlayment (SLU)

Self-leveling underlayment is a cement-based compound designed to correct uneven subfloors before installing various flooring types. It is mixed with water and poured, flowing out to create an exceptionally smooth and flat surface, effectively eliminating dips and humps up to several inches. It is crucial for installations of large format tiles or delicate engineered wood where subfloor flatness is paramount. While it offers excellent leveling and quick drying times (often ready for light traffic in hours), it often requires professional application due to its specific mixing and pouring requirements for proper flow and curing. My experience shows SLU is a great choice for ensuring a perfectly flat base, critical for high-quality finished flooring.

Specialty Underlayments

There are also specialized underlayments designed for unique needs. These include heated floor underlayments, often thin mats or membranes with channels for electric heating cables, which facilitate radiant heating systems and provide an even heat distribution. Another type is integrated moisture barrier underlayments, which combine cushioning and sound dampening with a heavy-duty vapor barrier, often with overlapped and sealed edges, providing extreme moisture protection, essential for concrete slabs. These specialized options address unique challenges and provide targeted solutions for complex installations, ensuring specific performance criteria are met.

The selection process for underlayment involves balancing performance needs with material compatibility and budget. We will now discuss the key factors to consider to ensure you make the best choice for your project.

---

What factors should you consider when choosing underlayment?

When selecting underlayment, consider flooring type, subfloor condition, room usage, desired performance features like sound and moisture control, budget, and manufacturer recommendations. These factors directly influence the best choice, ensuring optimal flooring longevity and comfort.

Choosing the right underlayment is not just about picking a type; it involves a careful evaluation of several factors. As a quality control professional, I emphasize a holistic approach to ensure optimal performance and longevity for the flooring system, avoiding costly re-installations.

Flooring Material Type

The type of finished flooring dictates the underlayment. Hardwood, laminate, tile, and vinyl each have specific underlayment requirements. For example, solid hardwood needs a breathable underlayment like felt or rosin paper, allowing the wood to expand and contract naturally. In contrast, rigid materials like porcelain tile require a completely stable and rigid base, often achieved with cement board or SLU, to prevent cracking. Using the wrong underlayment can void your flooring warranty and lead to premature failure.

Subfloor Condition

The condition of your subfloor plays a big part in underlayment choice. If the subfloor has minor imperfections or is uneven, a self-leveling underlayment or a thicker, cushioning foam might be needed to create a flat surface. If moisture is an issue, especially with concrete slabs, a robust vapor barrier with a perm rating below 0.1 is essential. I always advise assessing the subfloor thoroughly for moisture content, flatness, and structural integrity before making any decisions.

Room Usage and Foot Traffic

Consider how the room will be used. High-traffic areas, such as hallways or commercial spaces, or spaces where noise reduction is critical (like a second-story bedroom), will benefit from durable, sound-dampening underlayments like high-density rubber or cork. For lighter use areas, like guest bedrooms, a standard foam or felt might be sufficient. Understanding the anticipated wear and tear helps match the underlayment’s resilience to the room’s demands.

Desired Performance Characteristics

What specific performance do you need from your floor? If sound insulation is a top priority, look for underlayments with high STC and IIC ratings. If résistance à l'humidité is paramount due to a damp environment, a multi-layer underlayment with an integrated vapor barrier is a must. For thermal insulation, especially over cold concrete, an underlayment with a good R-value can contribute to energy efficiency. Prioritizing these features ensures the underlayment addresses your specific functional needs.

Budget Considerations

Underlayment costs vary significantly, ranging from under $0.50 per square foot for basic foam to over $3.00 per square foot for premium rubber or cork. While it is important to stay within budget, remember that investing in a higher-quality underlayment can save money in the long run by extending the life of your flooring, improving comfort, and avoiding costly repairs or re-installations due to moisture or sound issues. I have seen many cases where cutting corners here led to bigger problems later, outweighing initial savings.

Flooring Manufacturer’s Recommendations

Always check the flooring manufacturer’s recommendations for underlayment. Many manufacturers specify acceptable underlayment types, thicknesses, and installation methods to maintain their warranty. Following these guidelines ensures compatibility, optimal performance, and importantly, keeps your warranty valid. Deviating from these recommendations can lead to unexpected issues and voided warranties.

Choosing the right underlayment is a blend of understanding product specifications and real-world application needs. Proper installation is just as vital as the selection process. Now, we will discuss key installation tips and best practices to ensure your underlayment performs as expected.

---

What are the best installation tips and practices?

Proper underlayment installation requires a clean, level, and repaired subfloor. Use the correct laying methods for each underlayment type, ensuring sealed seams and proper acclimation to prevent future issues and ensure optimal performance.

Even the best underlayment will underperform if not installed correctly. As a quality control manager, I know the importance of meticulous installation. These tips ensure your underlayment provides maximum benefit and contributes to a durable, high-quality flooring system.

Préparation du support

Before installing any underlayment, ensure the subfloor is clean, dry, level, and free of defects. This means sweeping away debris, scraping off old adhesives, filling cracks with a suitable patching compound, and sanding down high spots to within 1/8 inch over 10 feet. A well-prepared subfloor is the foundation for a successful underlayment installation, preventing unevenness, squeaks, and potential damage to the finished flooring. Neglecting this step often leads to uneven flooring and premature wear.

Correct Laying Methods for Different Underlayment Types

Each underlayment type has specific installation instructions that must be followed. For example, felt underlayment is typically rolled out parallel to the flooring direction and stapled every 6-8 inches along the edges. Foam underlayments are often laid perpendicular to the flooring planks, with seams taped using manufacturer-recommended moisture-resistant tape. Cement board needs to be thin-set onto the subfloor and secured with corrosion-resistant screws spaced every 8 inches. Always follow the manufacturer’s guidelines for cutting, positioning, and fastening the material. I emphasize strict adherence to these instructions in all our manufacturing processes to ensure product performance.

Seam and Edge Sealing

Properly sealing seams and edges is important, especially for moisture barrier underlayments. For roll goods, use the recommended moisture-resistant tape (e.g., 2-inch wide self-adhesive tape) to ensure a continuous barrier against moisture. Overlap guidelines are critical; some require butt joints while others need an overlap of a few inches. This step is often overlooked but is very important for preventing water vapor from migrating through seams and damaging the finished flooring.

Acclimation Considerations

Some underlayments, particularly those made from natural materials like cork or wood-based products like plywood, require acclimation to the room’s temperature and humidity before installation. This typically involves laying out the underlayment in the installation area for 24-48 hours. This process allows the material to adjust to the ambient conditions, preventing unwanted expansion or contraction after installation, which can lead to buckling, gapping, or other issues in the finished floor. I always ensure our products come with clear acclimation guidelines to prevent these common problems.

Proper installation ensures the underlayment performs its intended functions, protecting your investment and ensuring a beautiful, long-lasting floor.

---

Conclusion

Selecting the correct underlayment is not just an option, it is a requirement. It is vital for enhancing your floor’s performance, durability, and lifespan. For complex installations or specific project needs, always consult with professionals to ensure compliance with building codes and manufacturer warranties.

Ready to optimize your flooring project with the perfect underlayment that meets your specific performance and budget needs? Contact our team today for a custom quote or to request free samples. We are here to help you achieve the best possible results with our expert knowledge and high-quality underlayment solutions.